Compound Bow Comparator

This unique bow comparison tool is capable of comparing bows at the version level. You can choose up to 10 compound bows to compare reviews, ratings, specs, pictures, and prices. Click the 'Add one more' button to add a new bow to your list. Alternatively, if you want to exclude a particular bow, click the 'remove' link. Once you are ready to compare, click the 'Compare' button.
Manufacturer
1
remove
2
remove
3
remove
 
Compared bows
Version2009 Hoyt SuperHawk2011 PSE Bow Madness2010 Diamond Black Ice FLX
Image
Note: images may not represent the selected versions: only 1 image per model is currently stored in our database.
Hoyt SuperHawkPSE Bow MadnessDiamond Black Ice
Specifications
(selected versions)
2009 Hoyt SuperHawk2011 PSE Bow Madness2010 Diamond Black Ice FLX
Brace Height7.5 "7 "7.25 "
AtA Length31 "32 "31.75 "
Draw Length25.5 " - 30.5 "25 " - 30 "25 " - 30 "
Draw Weight40 lbs - 70 lbs40 lbs - 70 lbs40 lbs - 70 lbs
IBO Speed306 fps323 fps - 331 fps310 fps - 318 fps
Weight4.1 lbs3.85 lbs3.8 lbs
Let-Off75% 75% 65% - 80%
Editor reviews
Hoyt SuperHawkPSE Bow MadnessDiamond Black Ice
Summary
Summary review written by our editors.

The Hoyt SuperHawk was Hoyt's mid-priced answer for the bowhunter who wanted the brand's engineering in a traditional laminated-limb bow, and judged on that brief it delivers. You get a compact, easy-handling 31-inch hunting bow at a light 4.1 pounds, the most forgiving brace in its class at 7.5 inches, a smooth-leaning M4 Cam & 1/2 at 306 fps IBO and 75% let-off, and the quiet appeal of a proven XT 500 laminated limb that has a fifteen-year track record behind it now. Drawing one, what stands out is how undramatic it is - a rounded cycle, a settled wall, and a brace that quietly forgives a rushed shot - which is exactly what makes a bow like this easy to shoot well in the field. Because it left production after a single 2009 season, today's buyer is shopping the used rack and should budget for fresh strings and cables, but the underlying hardware is sound Hoyt engineering that has aged gracefully. It is an excellent value hunting bow for the whitetail and hog hunter who prizes a forgiving, no-drama shot and a compact frame over chasing the speed chart. Buyers who want the most velocity in this class should look at the PSE Bow Madness, and those who want the widest tuning and let-off adjustability should look at the Diamond Black Ice. Read full review...

Being in the mid-price range, the PSE Bow Madness is a great quality bow that can easily outperform more expensive competitor bows with similar characteristics. Outfitted with a highly efficient single cam system, this bow is smooth to draw and hold. With the pre-loaded limbs and comfortable grip, this bow has minimal shock and vibration and is nice to shoot. While being lightweight and stable, this bow is a great choice for those shooters who cover a lot of ground or who prefer light and stable rigs generating fast speeds. Read full review...

No editors' review yet.
Please see user reviews below.

Hoyt SuperHawkPSE Bow MadnessDiamond Black Ice
Pros
  • Traditional XT 500 laminated limbs - the proven, time-tested solid-limb build Hoyt has run for decades, simple to live with and long on durability
  • Light 4.1 lb mass on a compact 31-inch frame - easy to pack into the backcountry and quick to swing on and steer inside a treestand or ground blind
  • Forgiving 7.5-inch brace height, the most generous in its class - gives a slightly imperfect release real margin, which suits a newer or casual hunter
  • Honest 306 fps hunting speed from a smooth M4 Cam & 1/2 at 75% let-off - a manageable draw and a hunting-friendly hold rather than a speed-cam fight
  • low hand shock and vibration
  • no bow press is required to adjust the draw length
  • comfortable grip
  • great value for money
  • accurate bow with a very smooth draw cycle
  • quiet bow with little hand shock
  • lightweight yet well balanced
  • draw length can be adjusted easily without using a bow press
Hoyt SuperHawkPSE Bow MadnessDiamond Black Ice
Cons
  • Discontinued after a single 2009 season, so today it is strictly a used-market buy - budget a fresh set of strings and cables from any pro shop, which also refreshes the aging factory string
  • Draw length is set by rotating the M4 module rather than a modern tool-less dial - a straightforward pro-shop adjustment, not the turn-a-dial-at-home change that current cams allow
  • standard strings could be of better quality
  • could be a faster bow
User reviews & ratings
Group all versions of the same model
Show selected versions only
Aggregate rating
Total aggregate rating for all versions
Hoyt SuperHawk
(total rating for all versions)
PSE Bow Madness
(total rating for all versions)
Diamond Black Ice
(total rating for all versions)
model not rated yet

    out of 4 reviews
    • This bow is the best bow out there for your money, fast, accurate, dependable.
      by Billy Bob from Albuquarque, NM
    • Smooth and fast!
      by Brent Laner from New Phila Ohio
    • Best bow for the money. Far exceeding bows costing twice as much.
      by Steve Lunde from Tucson, az
    • Awesome deer killing machine I don't think I ever want a different bow!! My kind of bow
      by Justin Gray from poynette wi
    • Read all user reviews

    out of 9 reviews
    • Smoothest shooting bow I have owned.
      by Team Shark from Dallas, Texas
    • I believe the Black Ice is an excellent all around bow for either hunting or 3D shooting.
      by Mark Drake from Kettering, Ohio
    • The perfect bow in every category except blazing speed
      by David Eppel from North Georgia
    • Smooth draw and solid backwall. Pleasure to shoot.
      by Chris Fowler from Laurel, Md
    • Read all user reviews
    Price comparisons
    Hoyt SuperHawkPSE Bow MadnessDiamond Black Ice
    Where to buy
    Best online deals available right now
    Sellers:
    eBay, Cabelas

    $200 to $650
     
    Compare prices
    Sellers:
    eBay

    $250
     
    Compare prices