Mathews Legacy Review

Mathews Legacy

Average user rating

out of 15 user reviews
eBay logo
  from $325

Pros

  • Accurate bow with a forgiving brace height
  • Has a smooth draw cycle
  • Quiet rig with little hand shock and vibration
  • Good for hunting, can also be used for 3D shooting
  • One of the hottest selling Mathews bows (even after being discontinued)

Cons

  • Draw length specific eccentric system
  • Could be a bit lighter and faster

Video

content from YouTube

Editors' review

The Mathews Legacy is an older Mathews bow that was manufactured from 2002 until 2004. Ideal for hunting, this quality rig is also used by some archers for 3D shooting. With a good silencing package, this bow has little shock and vibration and delivers quiet shots. While the Legacy is not a speed monster, it's fast enough for many hunting situations.

Riser, Limbs, and Grip

The AeroRiser is 100% fully-machined and is designed to reduce bow mass weight. Despite this design, the Legacy is not as lightweight as some modern bows with similar specs. The bow comes with parallel limbs to reduce vibration and make it quieter. Although some shooters like the new Mathews Competition grip, others say it is not that comfortable and needs to be replaced.

Eccentric system

Mathews's new StraightLine MaxCam 3 system is the driving force behind reported IBO speeds reaching 308 feet per second. This cam-specific eccentric system is not adjustable and requires new cams for adjusting the draw length. While this design is a bit restrictive, overall shootability is better because each cam is specifically tuned to deliver optimal performance for a particular draw length. Cams are available from 24" to 30" in half-inch increments. The let-off is 70%.To deliver faster speeds, smoother draw cycle, and reduce recoil, the StraightLine MaxCam 3 is oversized and has a weight on its perimeter. This weight is an essential part of the whole system and is designed to deliver smooth release and reduce vibration.

Draw cycle / Shootability

The Mathews Legacy is a smooth drawing bow although it's a tad stiffer than the ever popular Mathews Switchback. While some shooters say the Legacy pulls a little bit harder than the Switchback, overall they are very happy with the draw cycle for the speeds it produces.

Silencing system / Quietness and vibration

Outfitted with an effective silencing package (parallel limb design, harmonic dampeners, string suppressors, and over-sized perimeter weight), the Legacy is a quiet bow with little hand shock and vibration.

Great hunting bow suitable for 3D shooting

The Mathews Legacy is a very solid hunting bow as noted by many shooters. While some people say this rig could be faster, others believe it is fast enough for their hunting needs. At a forgiving brace height (7.5 inches) and measuring 34" from axle to axle, the Mathews Legacy can also be used for 3D shooting. While there are better 3D bows out there, many archers successfully use the Legacy for 3D shooting and say that the Legacy is a good all around bow.

One of the hottest selling Mathews bows

Having explored a lot of feedback about this bow, we can confirm that this is one of the most popular Mathews rigs ever. Many archers say that they feel no need to upgrade their old Mathews Legacy to a new bow because it shoots perfectly well. Despite this rig has been discontinued, people still enjoy shooting it. Buying a used Mathews Legacy is not very easy because not many people are giving them up.

Summary

To conclude, the Mathews Legacy is a quality hunting bow that was (and still is) very popular among hunters. Although the Legacy could be a bit lighter and faster, it's a very good shooter: quiet, smooth, and forgiving. Despite it's been discontinued by Mathews, this rig is still very popular and is a hot seller at the used bow market. Ideal for hunting, it can also be used for 3D shooting.

User Reviews

  • 16 reviews
  • ( out of 15 reviews for all versions)
Still my bow of choice.

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: If feels like an extension of my arm when I shoot. Very quiet and I love the feel and performance of the bow.

Cons: I really do not have any cons.

Full review:

The bow is easy to shoot and great for hunting. Although there are faster bows, I have never had a deer jump the string with this bow. I will be using mine again this season (2024). I have so much experience with this bow, there are no surprises or changes that need to be made when practicing for an upcoming season.

Thank you to Matthews for making such a great bow! I bought the bow new in 2002,

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: This bow is like a part of me. I hang it up in the tree hunt out of ladder stands I know what precisely where it's at I always shoot sitting down, It draws easy. Has a firm back wall!

Cons: It's a little heavy compared to the new bows, and it's a little longer than some of the axle to axle short bows but I just won't change right now!

Full review:

Everything is pretty much been said here. I love my Matthew's Legacy. I leave it Hang on the wall in my basement most of the year, Just to look at it. I still think the new bows are ugly, too black and modern looking!
When I pull my crossbow up into a tree it feels like a foreign object. A great big high strung heavy for an object!

When I hang my Legacy next to me in the tree, my hand automatically goes to the handle through the rope to the beautiful wooden grip, into a draw and generally through a bucks boiler room every fall.

This bow made me a much better more accurate bow hunter. I started out with a 70 lb Pierson spoiler with an overdraw and it was a monster to draw. This bow has been a dream and it's creator, the Matthews Corp. And Matt McPherson are second to none in quality!

You've heard many times of rifles handed down for generations and lasting for a lifetime, but not many bows!

The Matthew's Legacy, taken care of properly is a lifetime bow at least for me, as witnessed by my last 20 years since I bought it!

Best First Bow Ever

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Very quiet and built like a tank!

Cons: Tad bit on the heavy side.

Full review:

I went to my local shop to browse the inventory and get fitted for my first bow. Saw this old legacy hanging on the used rack for $330 and it was already cammed for my draw length so I had it set up. Shot like a dream. The shop got me dialed in at 20 yards with three inch groups. Best first bow ever!

A classic that holds up 20 years later

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Quiet, Smooth, Well Balanced, Accurate and Forgiving

Cons: It’s getting older every year

Full review:

Legacy is a smooth, quiet, bullseye, animal dropping piece of art. Is very forgiving and memorable shooting bow. Has a comfortable feeling and balance while shooting. I bought my bow new in 2002 bare after trying it out at the local Archery Shop. I had been shooting a Bear Whitetail and was receptive to the idea of a new bow. The tight groups and arrows touching had me hooked with no sights or rest in the bullseye. I couldn’t throw my money at him fast enough asking to be set up. I believe being measured and having a bow set up for the shooter is a must. I’ve always been a fan of a single pin sight and set myself up with an HHA early on. This rig has been reliable, accurate, and enjoyable to shoot for 20 years now. I’m evening lucky enough to be gifted another Legacy from my neighbor all set up since he can no longer pull a bow with his back ailments.

16 years and going strong

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Accurate, forgiving

Cons: None

Full review:

I love my Legacy it is smooth, forgiving and ACCURATE! I bought it new in 2005 and have never even thought of replacing it. I shoot it with a Trap Door fall away rest and Trophy Ridge sights. The first time I ever shot it at 20 yards I ruined an arrow. I cannot shoot at the same spot at 20 yards due to busting nocks and ripping fletching. In 2015 I shot through (double lung) a cow elk at 60 yards.

My favorite of the matthews solo cam line

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Smooth and forgiving solid
wall fast enough for any hunting situation and a blast to shoot.

Cons: Could a little faster but not a concern or problem in hunting situations.

Full review:

I simply like everything about this bow. It's the kind of bow once you shoot it it sticks to you. Go out and find a legacy if you're looking for the best solo cam matthews ever made.
Sincerely. Christian Spider Waller .

I keep saying I am going to upgrade to a newer model, but why??

Version: 2003 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: The brace height and the smooth draw cycle.

Cons: It is heavy compared to the latest newer bows on the market.

Full review:

I have shot this bow for 14 seasons now and thought about upgrading. My archery pro shop owner talked me out of it. Don't trade up if you love what you have and it works for your situation. Out to 40 yards in the deer hunting woods, this bow is as deadly as any bow ever produced period. Like the whisker biscuit arrow rest, the Matthews Legacy is iconic.

Great Bow

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Reliable, never let me down. Shot dozens of deer, super quiet. Perfect eastern whitetail rig. Added new string, string stop and QAD drop away rest and it shoots like new. Love this bow!

Cons: Forgiving and accurate but a little slow for long range western hunting. No complaints

Full review:

I think this was one of the better early bows Mathews made. Very forgiving brace height. The length, weight (a bit on the heavy side) make this a very shootable, very quiet accurate bow. I have hunted in all weather conditions and never had a sqeak, or glitch with any component. Rock solid.

I can't get rid of it.

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: The draw cycle is nice. I have a 30% partial rotator cuff tear and a 70lb Legacy drew easier then a 70lb HTR.

Cons: Doesn't look as cool as my buddies new bow?

Full review:

I purchased this brand new in 2002 and shoot the newest Mathews each year. This wins each year.

I thought this year would be the upgrade year with the HTR (revolutionary technology like the Legacy in 02), but after loosing the 1st HTR arrow, the Legacy wins another year. I've killed dozens of deer, wild boar, 3 elk and 2 antelope.

Forgiving bow with longer then average (now days) ATA and brace height.
It's quite.
Two Piece quiver is awesome. The arrow gripper bottom part rides nicely against my pack belt while scrambling terrain in the mountains.
Easy to tune. Cam lean and twisting the cable and string to meet the exact BH and ATA is easy.
I've shoot this bow thousands upon thousands of times. Outside of replacing the string and cable every other year or so I had to replace the white washer disks on the cam once. It has never given me any issues.

great shoot bow, got it for a great deal, lil longer ATA than im use to shooting

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: solid back wall, smooth draw, quite and very good groups

Cons: lil have and longer ATA than im use to but getting use to it an love it more an more the more I shoot it

Full review:

older bow, added the dead end string stop and made it ever bette, qda fall away rest an tru glow sites, absolute sweet shoot bow for its age, unless they jus come out with a extremely better bow which I doubt happens will keep shooting it

This will be the 12th archery season that I have been using the Legacy. What a good investment.

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: quiet, accurate

Cons: none

Full review:

This will be the 12th archery season that I have been using the Legacy. What a good investment. I have no plans of upgrading untill this one falls apart. Have killed at least a dozen deer with this bow. Still using the original black gold fiber pin sight and quick tune rest. Have tossed around upgrading the sight and rest, but see no reason to being that this rig is still as accurate as it was when new in 2002.

Top notch quality from Mathews...as expected.

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: QUIET. Bought this bow in 2002, it's been shot thousands of times and still slinging tight groups at 40 yards. Added the focus grip, harmonic stabilizer, and dead end string stop. Makes it shoot even better.

Cons: To change draw lengths you need to buy an $80 cam from the company. Or find one used.

Full review:

I've literally shot this bow thousands of times, and it still performs like the day I bought it. I will never buy another brand of bow. Mathews 4 life. Legacy 4 life...or until it blows up or I drop it out of my stand.

smooth quiet fast and acurate easy easy to shoot

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: quiet fast smooth and easy to shoot and stable

Cons: NA

Full review:

best smoothest bow i have ever shot and it can even shoot a little distance if i needed to i shoot it every day over 70 times a day it shoots nice smooth quiet and fun never could ask for anything more out of a single cam bow

still love my Legacy

Version: 2002 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: very stable,smooth shooting, and deadly quiet

Cons: little on the heavy side, and cant use string wiskers not that there needed (have let many shops tie them on and have tryed tieing them my self and they will sling off after 5-8 shots)

Full review:

have been shooting my Legacy for 9 years now and wouldnt trade it for anything on the market today. i use it for 3D and for hunting. was asked the year i bought it what i would think of my pretty high dollar bow 10 years down the road. i dont think my opinion will change in the next fue months. its no longer the shinie new bow on the market but will still shoot side by side whith the best of them.

Great bow for hunting and 3D, very forgiving and very accurate. @50 yds I'm sending a dzn inside 6"

Version: 2004 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: Again very accurate no torque and very quite.

Cons: I wrap the grip for winter hunting, and I hate the stock quiver.

Full review:

great bow

Version: 2003 Mathews Legacy

Rating:

Pros: easy to shoot quiet short perfect for hunting

Cons: nothing

Full review:

easy setup for hunting.i have no qualms with my legacy.faster bows are on the market but you sacrifice brace height wich can effect accuracy especially in hunting situations where perfect positioning is not possible.

Add Your Review

1. Your rating:

(Hover the mouse over the stars and click to rate this bow)



(Enter the version of your your Mathews Legacy bow; required)


(Summarize your review in one line; required, max 100 characters)


(Tell us what you liked about this bow; required, max 250 characters)


(Tell us what you did not like about this bow; required, max 250 characters)


(Provide your detailed review by outlining what you like and dislike about this bow. For example, you may describe features, shootability, overall feeling, your bow setup, real IBO speeds, and your experience using this bow; optional, 200-5000 characters)


(Enter your full name; required, max 50 characters)


(Enter your location, ex. city, state, country; optional, max 50 characters)

9. Prove you are not a robot: